Google Analytics vs Plausible and Fathom vs cite-met: the short version
Google Analytics 4 (GA4) is free, deep, and tied into Google Ads. It also sends your visitor data to Google and leaves known bots out of your reports. Plausible and Fathom are light, cookieless tools with one-page dashboards, sold as subscriptions (Plausible can also be self-hosted for free). cite-met is a done-for-you service that hosts your site and shows which AI crawlers fetched which pages, something the other three can't show you. If you only need traffic numbers, GA4 or Plausible or Fathom will do it for less. cite-met isn't a drop-in replacement for any of them, and you can run it alongside them.
Where GA4 falls short
- →Your visitor data goes to Google, and GA4's tags set first-party cookies to tell users and sessions apart, which is why many sites show a consent banner for it.
- →It leaves known bots and spiders out of your reports automatically. You can't turn that off or see how much it excluded. That keeps human numbers clean, and it also means GA4 can't show you which AI crawlers fetched your pages.
- →Sampling can apply once a query passes its event quota, which Google puts at 10 million events for a standard property. It mostly affects Explorations rather than the standard reports.
- →Many small teams find the event model and the interface slow to learn next to a one-page dashboard.
- →It measures traffic. It doesn't host your site or fix anything on it.
Google Analytics vs Plausible and Fathom vs cite-met, at a glance
| Capability | Google Analytics | Plausible and Fathom | cite-met |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it costs | Standard edition is free | Paid subscription (Plausible can be self-hosted for free) | Paid, done-for-you plans (see pricing) |
| Cookies | First-party cookies; many sites show a consent banner | Cookieless; both say no consent banner is needed for analytics | Cookieless, server-side |
| Where your data lives | The vendor's cloud (Plausible can be self-hosted) | A database we run for you on Cloudflare | |
| Human traffic, sources, geography | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Visits from AI assistants (people clicking a link in ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot) | Yes, in the AI Assistant channel since May 2026 | Yes, as referral sources | Yes, as entry sources in visitor journeys |
| AI crawler visits by page | No. Known bots are excluded | No. The script runs in browsers | Yes, as fetches (not citations) |
| Visitor journeys | Yes, in Explorations | Aggregate stats, not individual journeys | Yes, one day at a time |
| Google Ads audiences and conversion import | Yes, deep | No | No |
| Hosts your site | No | No | Yes |
| Scores your site and fixes failing checks | No | No | Yes (CiteMET Score) |
| Open source or self-host | No | Plausible: yes. Fathom: no | No |
What cite-met adds, and what it doesn't
AI crawler visibility
cite-met reads requests on the server, so it records AI crawlers that a browser script never sees: the AI search crawlers (OAI-SearchBot, Claude-SearchBot, PerplexityBot) and the fetchers that act when a person asks (ChatGPT-User, Claude-User, Perplexity-User). You see which pages they fetched and when. It records fetches, not citations.
Hosting and fixes in the same place
We host your site on Cloudflare's edge, score it with the CiteMET Score, and fix the failing checks. On sites we host, analytics needs no tracking script. You'd otherwise stitch this together from a counter, a host and a crawl tool.
Cookieless, server-side journeys
Sessions are linked by a daily-salted hash and the raw IP is never stored, so a journey is one day's path, not a profile that follows someone around.
What cite-met is not
It's a paid, done-for-you service, not a free counter. It can't tell you whether an AI answer cited you: use Bing Webmaster Tools' AI Performance report and Google Search Console's Generative AI performance report for that. If you rely on GA4's Google Ads audiences and conversion imports, keep GA4.
The fair take
What Google Analytics is genuinely good at
- The standard edition is free, and it's the industry default, with plenty of tutorials, agencies and integrations.
- Deep integration with Google Ads, Search Console and BigQuery.
- Segments, funnels, Explorations and audience building for teams that invest the time.
- Visits that arrive from a link in an AI assistant show up as sessions, usually with a source such as chatgpt.com, because those are people loading your page.
What Plausible and Fathom do well
- One-page dashboards that need little or no training.
- Cookieless. Both say you don't need a consent banner for their analytics.
- Light scripts. Plausible says its script is a fraction of the size of Google Analytics'.
- Plausible is open source, and its Community Edition is free to self-host. The cloud service is a paid subscription. Fathom is a paid, hosted service, priced by monthly pageviews, with a free trial.
Who should pick which
Pick cite-met if: You want to know which AI crawlers fetch your pages, you'd like hosting, analytics and fixes handled by one team, and you're happy to pay for a managed service instead of a counter.
Stick with Google Analytics if: You run Google Ads, you rely on GA4 audiences or conversion imports, or you need Explorations. Keep GA4, and add other tools only for what it can't do.
Pick Plausible and Fathom if: You want simple, cookieless traffic numbers for a modest monthly fee, or Plausible's free self-hosted edition, and AI crawler visibility isn't a concern yet.
Pricing
GA4's standard edition is free. Fathom is priced by monthly pageviews with a free trial, and Plausible sells a paid cloud subscription alongside its free self-hosted edition. We don't quote their prices here because they change, so check their pricing pages. cite-met is a done-for-you service rather than a counter: the plans on the pricing page bundle hosting, analytics, the CiteMET Score and site monitoring. If all you need is traffic numbers, a counter costs less.
Guides
- How to Track ChatGPT Traffic in GA4 (and What GA4 Can't Show You)
ChatGPT visits are in GA4's AI Assistant channel; its crawlers are only in your server logs; mentions need a prompt set.
- How Accurate Is AI Crawler Analytics? We Audited Ours
An audit of cite-met's own AI crawler and AI visit numbers: credential probes under assistant names, tracker fetches, and how to verify bots.
Sources
- Google Analytics Help: Known bot-traffic exclusion
- Google Analytics Help: About data sampling
- Google Analytics Help: What's new (AI Assistant channel, 13 May 2026)
- Google Analytics Help: Default channel group
- Google Search Central: AI features and your website
- Google Analytics Help: Cookie usage on websites
- Plausible: Community Edition and self-hosting
- Fathom: Pricing
- Bing Webmaster Tools: AI Performance
See your AI-visibility score in 60 seconds
Run a free scan on your live site, no signup, and see whether search and AI crawlers can reach and read your pages. Then host, measure, and improve it all in one place.